I wonder if it is possible to have an easy authentication method that is restful, fast and provides a litte security.
SSL is not an option, because I can't rely on a valid SSL Certificate on the server of clients. Also HMAC is not really possible because the body of the request should be signed, when used properly, but in my case that body could be a large file. Further should the authentication be possible with JavaScript/AJAX.
I thought about something really simple. What's the problem with that one:
HEADER: X-Authentication: timestamp:username:sha256(timestamp:password)
The server knows the users password and could check the hash, the timestamp is used to only allow request that took place e.g. 10 seconds before. The replay window would be extremly small, and there are no sessions on the serverside.
If the hash is cracked the attacker knows the password and has unlimited access.
Alternative would be to use
HEADER: X-Authentication: timestamp:username:HMAC(password, 'timestamp+request-method+verb')
What's the way to go? I'm not a security pro, maybe storing the session on the server would be better (but not RESTful)?