Without more information it will be difficult to help you debug this, especially why it works in one service but not in the other. However:
Instead of trying to fix the problem in your code you might want to remove the windows altogether, and use PostThreadMessage() instead of PostMessage(). For the posting of messages to work correctly you need a message loop, but not necessarily receiving windows.
Edit: I'm trying to reply to all your answers in one go.
First - if you want to make your life easy you should really check out OmniThreadLibrary by gabr. I don't know whether it does work in a Windows service application, I don't even know whether that has been tried yet. You could ask in the forum. It has however a lot of great features and is worth looking into, if only for the learning effect.
But of course you can also program this for yourself, and you will have to for Delphi versions prior to Delphi 2007. I will simply add some snippets from our internal library, which has evolved over the years and works in several dozen programs. I don't claim it to be bug-free though. You can compare it with your code, and if anything sticks out, feel free to ask and I'll try to clarify.
This is the simplified Execute() method of the worker thread base class:
procedure TCustomTestThread.Execute;
var
Msg: TMsg;
begin
try
while not Terminated do begin
if (integer(GetMessage(Msg, HWND(0), 0, 0)) = -1) or Terminated then
break;
TranslateMessage(Msg);
DispatchMessage(Msg);
if Msg.Message = WM_USER then begin
// handle differently according to wParam and lParam
// ...
end;
end;
except
on E: Exception do begin
...
end;
end;
end;
It is important to not let exceptions get unhandled, so there is a top-level exception handler around everything. What you do with the exception is your choice and depends on the application, but all exceptions have to be caught, otherwise the application will get terminated. In a service your only option is probably to log them.
There is a special method to initiate thread shutdown, because the thread needs to be woken up when it is inside of GetMessage():
procedure TCustomTestThread.Shutdown;
begin
Terminate;
Cancel; // internal method dealing with worker objects used in thread
DoSendMessage(WM_QUIT);
end;
procedure TCustomTestThread.DoSendMessage(AMessage: Cardinal;
AWParam: integer = 0; ALParam: integer = 0);
begin
PostThreadMessage(ThreadID, AMessage, AWParam, ALParam);
end;
Posting WM_QUIT will cause the message loop to exit. There is however the problem that code in descendant classes could rely on Windows messages being properly handled during shutdown of the thread, especially when COM interfaces are used. That's why instead of a simple WaitFor() the following code is used to free all running threads:
procedure TCustomTestController.BeforeDestruction;
var
i: integer;
ThreadHandle: THandle;
WaitRes: LongWord;
Msg: TMsg;
begin
inherited;
for i := Low(fPositionThreads) to High(fPositionThreads) do begin
if fPositionThreads[i] <> nil then try
ThreadHandle := fPositionThreads[i].Handle;
fPositionThreads[i].Shutdown;
while TRUE do begin
WaitRes := MsgWaitForMultipleObjects(1, ThreadHandle, FALSE, 30000,
QS_POSTMESSAGE or QS_SENDMESSAGE);
if WaitRes = WAIT_OBJECT_0 then begin
FreeAndNil(fPositionThreads[i]);
break;
end;
if WaitRes = WAIT_TIMEOUT then
break;
while PeekMessage(Msg, 0, 0, 0, PM_REMOVE) do begin
TranslateMessage(Msg);
DispatchMessage(Msg);
end;
end;
except
on E: Exception do
// ...
end;
fPositionThreads[i] := nil;
end;
end;
This is in the overridden BeforeDestruction() method because all threads need to be freed before the destructor of the descendant controller class begins to free any objects the threads might use.