c# - 表达式树 - 在外部 lambda 中编译内部 lambda - 范围解析

Question

我正在创建表达式树，有一种情况我需要在另一个 lambda 中创建一个 lambda，并将内部的一个存储在一个类中，然后将该类添加到表达式树中。这是我正在尝试做的简单示例（此代码无法编译）：

using System;
using System.Collections.Generic;
using System.Linq;
using System.Text;
using System.Linq.Expressions;

namespace SimpleTest {
    public class LambdaWrapper {
        private Delegate compiledLambda;
        public LambdaWrapper(Delegate compiledLambda) {
            this.compiledLambda = compiledLambda;
        }
        public dynamic Execute() {
            return compiledLambda.DynamicInvoke();
        }
    }

    public class ForSO {

        public ParameterExpression Param;

        public LambdaExpression GetOuterLambda() {
            IList<Expression> lambdaBody = new List<Expression>();
            Param = Expression.Parameter(typeof(object), "Param");
            lambdaBody.Add(Expression.Assign(
                            Param, 
                            Expression.Constant("Value of 'param' valiable"))
                          );

            lambdaBody.Add(Expression.Call(
                            null, 
                            typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"), 
                            Param)
                          );

            Delegate compiledInnerLambda = GetInnerLambda().Compile();
            LambdaWrapper wrapper = new LambdaWrapper(compiledInnerLambda);
            lambdaBody.Add(Expression.Constant(wrapper));
            //lambdaBody.Add(GetInnerLambda());
            return Expression.Lambda(
                        Expression.Block(
                                new ParameterExpression[] { Param }, 
                                lambdaBody));
        }

        public LambdaExpression GetInnerLambda() {
            return Expression.Lambda(
                    Expression.Block(
                        Expression.Call(null, 
                                typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"), 
                                Expression.Constant("Inner lambda start")),
                        Expression.Call(null, 
                                typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"), 
                                Param),
                        Expression.Call(null, 
                                typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"), 
                                Expression.Constant("Inner lambda end"))
                    )
                );
        }

        public static void Write(object toWrite) {
            Console.WriteLine(toWrite);
        }

        public static void Main(string[] args) {
            ForSO so = new ForSO();
            LambdaWrapper wrapper = so.GetOuterLambda().Compile()
                                      .DynamicInvoke() as LambdaWrapper;
            wrapper.Execute();
            //(so.GetOuterLambda().Compile().DynamicInvoke() as Delegate).DynamicInvoke();
        }
    }
}

问题出GetInnerLambda().Compile()在GetOuterLambda方法上。我知道一种解决方案 - 它位于代码的注释部分。这样，一切正常，但我需要一个包装器作为返回值，而不是表达式子树（可以将内部 lambda 子树存储在 LambdaWrapper 中，然后再编译它，但会出现同样的问题）。

我得到的错误是Unhandled Exception: System.InvalidOperationException: variable 'Param' of type 'System.Object' referenced from scope '', but it is not defined.

如果我Param在内部 lambda 中添加块变量，代码会编译，但 Param 没有在外部 lambda 中分配值（这是有道理的）。

如何解决？

score 1 · Accepted Answer

好吧，既然你不能Param在你的内部 lambda 表达式中使用常量值，我建议你在你的表达式中添加一个 lambda 参数：

public LambdaExpression GetInnerLambda()
{
    var param = Expression.Parameter(typeof(object));
    return Expression.Lambda(
        Expression.Block(
            Expression.Call(null,
                typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"),
                Expression.Constant("Inner lambda start")),
            Expression.Call(null,
                typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"),
                param),
            Expression.Call(null,
                typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"),
                Expression.Constant("Inner lambda end"))
        ),
        param
    );
}

然后将参数的值存储在您的LambdaWrapper类中，稍后将其用作DynamicInvoke调用中的参数：

public class LambdaWrapper
{
    private object param;
    private Delegate compiledLambda;

    public LambdaWrapper(Delegate compiledLambda, object param)
    {
        this.compiledLambda = compiledLambda;
        this.param = param;
    }

    public dynamic Execute()
    {
        return compiledLambda.DynamicInvoke(param);
    }
}

这行得通，但唯一的问题是它会调用WriteLineon Param，这是一个 ParameterExpression 对象。要解决这个问题，您必须在表达式树中动态创建包装类：

//lambdaBody.Add(Expression.Constant(wrapper));
lambdaBody.Add(Expression.New(
    typeof(LambdaWrapper).GetConstructor(new[] { typeof(Delegate), typeof(object) }),
    Expression.Constant(compiledInnerLambda),
    Param)
);

然后它将使用分配的值Param。而且由于您不使用Paramoutside GetOuterLambda，因此您现在可以将其用作局部变量。

编辑：

这是我解决此问题的第二次尝试：

public LambdaExpression GetOuterLambda()
{
    ...
    //Delegate compiledInnerLambda = GetInnerLambda().Compile();
    //LambdaWrapper wrapper = new LambdaWrapper(compiledInnerLambda);

    lambdaBody.Add(Expression.New(
        typeof(LambdaWrapper).GetConstructor(new[] { typeof(Delegate) }),
        Expression.Call(
            Expression.Call(
                typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("GetInnerLambda", BindingFlags.Public | BindingFlags.Static),
                Param
            ),
            typeof(LambdaExpression).GetMethod("Compile", Type.EmptyTypes)
        )
    ));
    ...
}

public static LambdaExpression GetInnerLambda(object param)
{
    return Expression.Lambda(
        Expression.Block(
            Expression.Call(null,
                typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"),
                Expression.Constant("Inner lambda start")),
            Expression.Call(null,
                typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"),
                Expression.Constant(param)),
            Expression.Call(null,
                typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"),
                Expression.Constant("Inner lambda end"))
        )
    );
}

当您运行外部委托时，此方法会编译此内部 lambda。通过这样做，Param将在编译内部 lambda 之前分配。

score 0 · Accepted Answer

在 Balazs Tihanyi 的帮助下，我找到了完全符合我需要的解决方案。这需要做更多的工作，因为我必须创建活页夹，但我的主要项目已经有了它们，所以我为这个示例创建了虚拟活页夹。

这是我的最终解决方案：

using System;
using System.Collections.Generic;
using System.Linq;
using System.Text;
using System.Linq.Expressions;
using System.Reflection;
using System.Dynamic;


namespace SimpleTest {
    public class MyCreateBinder : CreateInstanceBinder {
        public MyCreateBinder(CallInfo info) : base(info) { }

        public override DynamicMetaObject FallbackCreateInstance(
                                        DynamicMetaObject target,
                                        DynamicMetaObject[] args,
                                        DynamicMetaObject errorSuggestion) {
            var param = args[0].Value;

            Type toCreate = target.Value as Type;
            var ctors = toCreate.GetConstructors()
                        .Where(c => c.GetParameters().Length == args.Length)
                        .ToArray();

            if (ctors.Length == 0)
                throw 
                    new Exception(
                      String.Format(
                      "Can not find constructor for '{0}' with {1} parameters",
                      toCreate, args.Length));
            ConstructorInfo ctorToUse = ctors[0];
            return new DynamicMetaObject(
                            Expression.New(
                                ctorToUse,
                                args.Select(a => a.Expression).ToList()),
                       BindingRestrictions.Empty);
        }
    }

    public class MySetMemberBinder : SetMemberBinder {

        public MySetMemberBinder(string name) : base(name, false) { }

        public override DynamicMetaObject FallbackSetMember(
                                DynamicMetaObject target,
                                DynamicMetaObject value,
                                DynamicMetaObject errorSuggestion) {

            throw new NotImplementedException();
        }
    }

    public class MyGetMemberBinder : GetMemberBinder {
        public MyGetMemberBinder(string name) : base(name, false) { }

        public override DynamicMetaObject FallbackGetMember(
                                        DynamicMetaObject target,
                                        DynamicMetaObject errorSuggestion) {
            throw new NotImplementedException();
        }
    }

    public class MyInvokeMemberBinder : InvokeMemberBinder {
        public MyInvokeMemberBinder(string name, CallInfo callInfo) 
            : base(name, false, callInfo) { }

        public override DynamicMetaObject FallbackInvokeMember(
                                    DynamicMetaObject target,
                                    DynamicMetaObject[] args,
                                    DynamicMetaObject errorSuggestion) {
            var a = this;
            throw new NotImplementedException();
        }

        public override DynamicMetaObject FallbackInvoke(
                                    DynamicMetaObject target,
                                    DynamicMetaObject[] args,
                                    DynamicMetaObject errorSuggestion) {
            throw new NotImplementedException();
        }
    }

    public class LambdaWrapper : IDynamicMetaObjectProvider {
        private Delegate compiledLambda;
        private LambdaExpression exp;

        public LambdaWrapper(LambdaExpression exp) {
            this.exp = exp;
            this.compiledLambda = exp.Compile();
        }
        public dynamic Execute(dynamic param) {
            return compiledLambda.DynamicInvoke(param);
        }

        public DynamicMetaObject GetMetaObject(Expression parameter) {
            return new MetaLambdaWrapper(parameter, this);
        }
    }

    public class MetaLambdaWrapper : DynamicMetaObject {
        public MetaLambdaWrapper(Expression parameter, object value) : 
            base(parameter, BindingRestrictions.Empty, value) { }

        public override DynamicMetaObject BindInvokeMember(
                                    InvokeMemberBinder binder,
                                    DynamicMetaObject[] args) {
            MethodInfo method = this.Value.GetType().GetMethod(binder.Name);
            return new DynamicMetaObject(
                        Expression.Call(
                            Expression.Constant(this.Value),
                                method,
                                    args.Select(a => a.Expression)),
                        BindingRestrictions.GetTypeRestriction(
                            this.Expression, 
                            typeof(LambdaWrapper)));
        }
    }


    public class ForSO {
        public ParameterExpression Param;
        public LambdaExpression GetOuterLambda() {
            Expression wrapper;
            IList<Expression> lambdaBody = new List<Expression>();
            Param = Expression.Parameter(typeof(object), "Param");
            lambdaBody.Add(Expression.Assign(
                            Param,
                            Expression.Constant("Value of 'param' variable"))
                          );
            lambdaBody.Add(Expression.Call(
                            null,
                            typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"),
                            Param)
                          );

            wrapper = Expression.Dynamic(
                                new MyCreateBinder(new CallInfo(1)),
                                typeof(object),
                                Expression.Constant(typeof(LambdaWrapper)),
                                Expression.Quote(GetInnerLambda()));


            lambdaBody.Add(
                Expression.Dynamic(
                    new MyInvokeMemberBinder("Execute", new CallInfo(1)),
                    typeof(object),
                    wrapper,
                Expression.Constant("calling inner lambda from outer")));

            lambdaBody.Add(wrapper);

            return Expression.Lambda(
                        Expression.Block(
                                new ParameterExpression[] { Param },
                                lambdaBody));
        }

        public LambdaExpression GetInnerLambda() {
            ParameterExpression innerParam = Expression.Parameter(
                                                typeof(object), 
                                                "innerParam");
            return Expression.Lambda(
                    Expression.Block(
                        Expression.Call(null,
                                typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"),
                                Expression.Constant("Inner lambda start")),
                        Expression.Call(null,
                                typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"),
                                innerParam),
                        Expression.Call(null,
                                typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"),
                                Param),
                        Expression.Call(null,
                                typeof(ForSO).GetMethod("Write"),
                                Expression.Constant("Inner lambda end"))
                    ),
                    innerParam
                );
        }

        public static void Write(object toWrite) {
            Console.WriteLine(toWrite);
        }

        public static void Main(string[] args) {
            Console.WriteLine("-----------------------------------");
            ForSO so = new ForSO();

            LambdaWrapper wrapper = (LambdaWrapper) so.GetOuterLambda()
                                                    .Compile()
                                                    .DynamicInvoke();
            Console.WriteLine("-----------------------------------");
            wrapper.Execute("Calling from main");
        }
    }

}

c# - 表达式树 - 在外部 lambda 中编译内部 lambda - 范围解析

2 回答 2

Related

Reference